• Virginia News
  • West Virginia News
  • National News
  • Login
  • My account
  • Subscribe
Subscribe For $2.50/month
Mountain Media, LLC
  • National News
  • WV State News
  • WV Newspapers
    • Calhoun Chronicle
    • Clay County Free Press
    • Mountain Messenger
    • Moorefield Examiner
    • Parsons Advocate
    • Pocahontas Times
    • Shinnston News & Harrison County Journal
    • Pendleton Times
    • Hashtag
  • WV Counties
    • Calhoun County
    • Clay County
    • Hardy County
    • Greenbrier County
    • Pocahontas County
    • Harrison County
    • Tucker County
  • VA State News
  • VA Newspapers
    • The Enterprise
    • Henry County Enterprise
    • Fincastle Herald
    • New Castle Record
    • News Journal
    • News Messenger
    • Roanoke Tribune
    • Salem Times Register
    • Vinton Messenger
  • VA Counties
    • Botetourt County
    • Craig County
    • Henry County
    • Montgomery County
      • News Messenger
      • News Journal
    • Patrick County
    • Salem County
      • Salem Times Register
      • Roanoke Tribune
      • Vinton Messenger
  • Press Releases
  • Contact
  • About Us
  • Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
Mountain Media, LLC
No Result
View All Result
Mountain Media, LLC
No Result
View All Result

Judge uses a slavery law to rule frozen embryos are property

March 10, 2023
in National News
0
0
SHARES
3
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

FAIRFAX, Va. (AP) — Frozen human embryos can legally be considered property, or “chattel,” a Virginia judge has ruled, basing his decision in part on a 19th century law governing the treatment of slaves.

The preliminary opinion by Fairfax County Circuit Court Judge Richard Gardiner – delivered in a long-running dispute between a divorced husband and wife – is being criticized by some for wrongly and unnecessarily delving into a time in Virginia history when it was legally permissible to own human beings.

“It’s repulsive and it’s morally repugnant,” said Susan Crockin, a lawyer and scholar at Georgetown University’s Kennedy Institute of Ethics and an expert in reproductive technology law.

Solomon Ashby, president of the Old Dominion Bar Association, a professional organization made up primarily of African American lawyers, called Gardiner’s ruling troubling.

“I would like to think that the bench and the bar would be seeking more modern precedent,” he said.

Gardiner did not return a call to his chambers Wednesday. His decision, issued last month, is not final: He has not yet ruled on other arguments in the case involving Honeyhline and Jason Heidemann, a divorced couple fighting over two frozen embryos that remain in storage.

Honeyhline Heidemann, 45, wants to use the embryos. Jason Heidemann objects.

Initially, Gardiner sided with Jason Heidemann. The law at the heart of the case governs how to divide “goods and chattels.” The judge ruled that because embryos could not be bought or sold, they couldn’t be considered as such and therefore Honeyhline Heidemann had no recourse under that law to claim custody of them.

But after the ex-wife’s lawyer, Adam Kronfeld, asked the judge to reconsider, Gardiner conducted a deep dive into the history of the law. He found that before the Civil War, it also applied to slaves. The judge then researched old rulings that governed custody disputes involving slaves, and said he found parallels that forced him to reconsider whether the law should apply to embryos.

In a separate part of his opinion, Gardiner also said he erred when he initially concluded that human embryos cannot be sold.

“As there is no prohibition on the sale of human embryos, they may be valued and sold, and thus may be considered ‘goods or chattels,’” he wrote.

Crockin said she’s not aware of any other judge in the U.S. who has concluded that human embryos can be bought and sold. She said the trend, if anything, has been to recognize that embryos have to be treated in a more nuanced way than as mere property.

Ashby said he was baffled that Gardiner felt a need to delve into slavery to answer a question about embryos, even if Virginia case law is thin on how to handle embryo custody questions.

“Hopefully, the jurisprudence will advance in the commonwealth of Virginia such that … we will no longer see slave codes” cited to justify legal rulings, he said.

Neither of the Heidemanns’ lawyers ever raised the slavery issue. They did raise other arguments in support of their cases, however.

Jason Heidemann’s lawyers said allowing his ex-wife to implant the embryos they created when they were married “would force Mr. Heidemann to procreate against his wishes and therefore violate his constitutional right to procreational autonomy.”

Honeyhline Heidemann’s lawyer, Kronfeld, argued that Honeyhline’s right to the embryos outweighs her ex-husband’s objections, partly because he would have no legal obligations to be their parent and partly because she has no other options to conceive biological children after undergoing cancer treatments that made her infertile.

Kronfeld also argued that the initial separation agreement the couple signed in 2018 already treated the embryos as property when they concurred — under a subheading titled “Division of Personal Property” — that the embryos would remain in cryogenic storage until a court ordered otherwise.

Gardiner has not yet ruled on the argument over Jason Heidemann’s procreational autonomy.

Previous Post

Letter claims cartel handed over men who killed Americans

Next Post

Lawyers: Former NBA star Shawn Kemp fired in self-defense

Next Post

Lawyers: Former NBA star Shawn Kemp fired in self-defense

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • National News
  • WV State News
  • WV Newspapers
  • WV Counties
  • VA State News
  • VA Newspapers
  • VA Counties
  • Press Releases
  • Contact
  • About Us
  • Subscribe

Mountain Media, LLC PO Box 429 Lewisburg, WV 24901 (304) 647-5724 Email: frontdesk@mountainmedianews.com

  • Login
  • Sign Up
Forgot Password?
Lost your password? Please enter your username or email address. You will receive a link to create a new password via email.
body::-webkit-scrollbar { width: 7px; } body::-webkit-scrollbar-track { border-radius: 10px; background: #f0f0f0; } body::-webkit-scrollbar-thumb { border-radius: 50px; background: #dfdbdb }
No Result
View All Result
  • National News
  • WV State News
  • WV Newspapers
    • Calhoun Chronicle
    • Clay County Free Press
    • Mountain Messenger
    • Moorefield Examiner
    • Parsons Advocate
    • Pocahontas Times
    • Shinnston News & Harrison County Journal
    • Pendleton Times
    • Hashtag
  • WV Counties
    • Calhoun County
    • Clay County
    • Hardy County
    • Greenbrier County
    • Pocahontas County
    • Harrison County
    • Tucker County
  • VA State News
  • VA Newspapers
    • The Enterprise
    • Henry County Enterprise
    • Fincastle Herald
    • New Castle Record
    • News Journal
    • News Messenger
    • Roanoke Tribune
    • Salem Times Register
    • Vinton Messenger
  • VA Counties
    • Botetourt County
    • Craig County
    • Henry County
    • Montgomery County
      • News Messenger
      • News Journal
    • Patrick County
    • Salem County
      • Salem Times Register
      • Roanoke Tribune
      • Vinton Messenger
  • Press Releases
  • Contact
  • About Us
  • Subscribe

Mountain Media, LLC PO Box 429 Lewisburg, WV 24901 (304) 647-5724 Email: frontdesk@mountainmedianews.com